I've tried to avoid weighing in on Amoris Laetitia until the dust settles, but that simply wasn't in the cards. For days, I've carried on an email correspondence with a Sixpacker. Our exchanges have covered a lot of things beside Amoris Laetitia, but that has been the main theme. So here I present the full exchange (to the point where I cut it off) between this Sixpacker and myself, carefully protecting his identity. You'll learn a lot of things by reading this. I welcome your comments, and would enjoy watching a debate among readers in the comments section.